But this assumption is not known to be true, and it is not the only conceivable one consistent with the observed facts mentioned earlier. The implicit assumption made in all the arguments discussed above was that the relationship between brain activity and consciousness was always one of cause to effect, and never that of effect to cause. The hidden premise behind this argument can be illustrated with the analogy of listening to music on a radio, smashing the radio’s receiver, and thereby concluding that the radio was producing the music. There is an implicit, unstated assumption behind this argument, and it is often unconsciously employed. However, this conclusion is not based on the evidence alone. For instance, one of the arguments mentioned earlier starts with the observation that a severe blow to the head can cause the cessation of consciousness from this it is concluded that consciousness is produced by a properly functioning brain, and so cannot exist in its absence. "All the arguments mentioned above that are opposed to the empirical possibility of survival are based upon a certain assumption of the relationship between mind and body that usually goes unstated. Choose reason, not group-think behavior.ĮDIT: I can even quote where he explicitly refutes the central point of Lets_Buttfuck_Jesus: Act like his peer yourself, and tell me where he is being incorrect. anybody? This is a philosophy paper, not a scientific study. Is it now that I'm supposed to see the light of your infinite wisdom and accept that I'm wrong?įirst of all, there isn't much to source, and do you really doubt that what he quotes from the other authors is false, or couldn't be stated by. No, you're just going to give me your gut reaction (surprise!), ad hominems and appeals to authority. Must have tools and links for /r/atheism usersĬommunity submitted images used by r/atheism r/atheism IRC channel r/atheism Discord Server FiltersĬlick the squares below to filter /r/atheism to specific topics or submission types Recommended: Reading, Kids Reading, Viewing, and Listening. Check our FAQ and WIKI Are you planning to: Read before posting: Subreddit CommandmentsĤ - All Images must be in a Self/Text post.ħ - Follow reddit's rules. All topics related to atheism, agnosticism and secular living are welcome. Welcome to r/atheism, the web's largest atheist forum. Welcome to r/atheism, please read our Rules, & our FAQ! Thinking of telling your parents? Read this first.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |